The-High-Republic – Cataclysm

The High Republic’s second series has seen its ups and downs. While I wasn’t a fan of the inaugural book, Path of Deceit, I did appreciate Convergence, even if it felt a tad intricate. The audio drama, The Battle for Jedha, resonated with me, and Cataclysm stands out as the pinnacle of wave II. It has a more fluid narrative than Convergence and paints a more expansive picture of the clash between the warring worlds, the ideologies of the Open Hand and Closed Fist, and the wider universe. I was pleased with how this book tied up several narratives, giving us glimpses into various locations when needed and with impressive character depth.

Xiri and Phan-to’s relationship insights and Axel’s journey of realization were highlights. There’s still some unfinished business between him and Gella, and the presence of the mother added intrigue.However, my qualm lies in the representation of the Jedi, notably in combat situations. The Jedi of the High Republic seem somewhat underwhelming, lacking the prowess that Jedi from the Old Republic exhibited. Those Jedi were formidable and showcased exceptional abilities. The ones in this series seem more vulnerable and less adept in utilizing the Force. I yearn for the Sith’s return as worthy adversaries, bringing with them intense lightsaber duels and deeper philosophical debates about the Force’s use. Still, we see glimpses of the latter in this narrative. March Thompson’s voice work on the audiobook remains top-tier. All in all, this is perhaps the most standout High Republic title since The Rising Storm.

I found this book engaging, particularly in its depiction of diverse Jedi factions uniting with allies against the Path of the Open Hand. The interactions between characters, especially Yaddle (a relatively lesser-known figure till now) and Yoda sharing a memorable Force moment, were definite standouts. Yet, I’m left with lingering questions. The transformation of the Path of the Open Hand from a seemingly peaceful, flower-distributing community to a formidable army of zealous warriors with high-grade weaponry is perplexing.

When and how did this shift occur? The overarching motives of the Path, as well as the reasons behind the escalating conflict between Eiram and E’ronoh, remain shrouded in mystery. Was the battle a premeditated strategy or an unforeseen outcome? Were the Leveler’s offspring born or transported from Planet X or a similar place? Additionally, the character featured on the jacket cover remains an enigma. Could it be Axel Greylark? While entertaining, I’m uncertain if this installment significantly propelled Phase I’s main narrative.